Are you looking for the best Eyebrow Pencils to buy? You’ve come to the right place! We’ve looked over hundreds of Makeup products to come up with this comprehensive list of the best Eyebrow Pencils you can buy right now. Many of these are best-selling and top rated products at popular cosmetic stores such as Sephora, Bergdorf Goodman, Nordstrom, C.O. Bigelow and Lush. In this post, we’re going to take a look at products from Benefit Cosmetics, MILK MAKEUP, Anastasia Beverly Hills, Anastasia Beverly Hills, and others. In this list we include Tinted Brow Gel by Anastasia Beverly Hills, ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush by Benefit Cosmetics, and Brow Gel by Anastasia Beverly Hills.

There are many things to consider before choosing makeup – quality, durability, skin tone and skin type. Understand your skin, face type, and complexion. It’s difficult to know exactly what you are looking for, but we try our best to make our list as precise as possible.

With the wide range of items to choose from in the cosmetic shops, it becomes quite a task to choose something that can suit your requirements and leave you looking gorgeous. Most people buy makeup on impulse and thus do not have the time to go through the merits of getting a particular product. The sellers understand this behavior and capitalize on it to increase their sales by offering good marketing promises.

So which is the best Eyebrow Pencils for you? Discover below.

Quick Look: 10 Best Eyebrow Pencils

  • Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel by Benefit Cosmetics
  • Brow Gel by Anastasia Beverly Hills
  • KUSH Fiber Brow Gel by MILK MAKEUP
  • Tinted Brow Gel by Anastasia Beverly Hills
  • ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush by Benefit Cosmetics
  • Arch Brow Volumizing Fiber Gel by Hourglass
  • ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush Mini by Benefit Cosmetics
  • Brow Tech To Go by Smashbox
  • 24-HR Brow Setter Shaping & Setting Gel by Benefit Cosmetics
  • BROWVO! Conditioning Primer Nutrient Rich Eyebrow Primer by Benefit Cosmetics
Below you will find product details, along with the most useful reviews and buy links for each Makeup product. This list will be updated with new products as they are released. So check back often.

Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel by Benefit Cosmetics

Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel Benefit Cosmetics

Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel is one of the best-selling products right now, with 3,709 reviews, it is rated 4.4 out of 5 stars. Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel has 100K ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it today for $24.

A brow-volumizing tinted gel with tiny microfibers that create natural-looking fullness and definition.

Benefit’s Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel contains tiny microfibers that adhere to skin and brow hairs, creating natural-looking brow volume. The custom tiny, tapered brush provides an easy, mess-proof application, and makes it easy to tame, tint, and volumize the look of your brows. The buildable formula is also water-resistant and long-wearing.

Beauty Tip:
Start your look with Benefit’s bestselling Precisely, My Brow Pencil (sold separately) for expertly full and defined brow looks.

Price: $24
Stars: 4.4 / 5
Reviews: 3,709

You can buy Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel at Sephora.

A reviewer who tried Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel said:

“I have naturally thick and WILD eyebrows and this helps to keep them in place without looking too dramatic. I like a more natural brow so I apply lightly but you can apply a little more heavily if you’d like. i have a scar in my brow and this camouflages it perfectly! I’ve never been one to do my brows because it’s too much work but this makes it easy.” – jgltan

“Laughter is the best cosmetic, so grin & wear it!” – Jean & Jane Ford, co-founders. In 1976, former models Jean and Jane Ford opened a quirky boutique in San Francisco where they introduced the world’s first “Fake-Its”…instant beauty solutions with laugh-out-loud names and creative packaging. Benefit quickly became one of the world’s most beloved makeup brands and garnered a cult following among models, makeup artists, and celebrities. Now carried in over 35 countries, goodtime gals “fake it ‘til they make it” with iconic bestsellers like Benetint, the POREfessional, and They’re Real! mascara.

Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel, $24
Buy It


Brow Gel by Anastasia Beverly Hills

Brow Gel Anastasia Beverly Hills

A clear gel for all hair colors that sets, defines, and holds brows in place all day.

Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars, Brow Gel by Anastasia Beverly Hills is another fantastic option. It currently has 3,145 reviews with 100K ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it for around $22.

This long-wearing clear gel sets and defines brows without fuss. The soothing chamomile formula also conditions hair and offers a lustrous, natural look.

Price: $22
Stars: 4.5 / 5
Reviews: 3,145

Brow Gel is available at Sephora.

Here is what one user said about Brow Gel:

“I’ve tried many different gels and this is my favorite. It might seem a bit pricey but it lasts forever. I use mine daily sometimes twice if I reapply my makeup. The best part is that it won’t flake off and leave a nasty residue like other gels” – brunettegal

Another reviewer said:

“This is definitely an amazing product. It holds your brows in place in a natural way. Not too pasty and no flakes. I have purchased in the past Brow Gel and it just isn’t the same. I don’t know why I didn’t buy this sooner.” – yaide

Brow Gel, $22
Buy It


KUSH Fiber Brow Gel by MILK MAKEUP

MILK MAKEUP KUSH Fiber Brow Gel

A tinted, vegan brow gel formulated with thickening, heart-shaped fibers and conditioning cannabis oil for long-lasting fullness, shape, and definition.

MILK MAKEUP’s KUSH Fiber Brow Gel is rated 4.3 out of 5 stars. This product has 16 reviews with 5,891 ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it for $18.

Do something dope for your brows. KUSH Fiber Brow Gel is for anyone looking to add some oomph to their brows. It’s packed with tinted, thickening, heart-shaped fibers that adhere to skin and hair for long-lasting fullness, shape, and definition. The hollow fibers are also filled with formula for another dose of volume. Cannabis oil fuses the heart-shaped fibers to brows for thickness without flaking. Like a hair mask for your brows, nourishing, cannabis oil also conditions, sets, and won’t cause stiffness. The tapered, tree-shaped brush with dense, firm bristles allows you to deposit gel evenly across your brows so each hair stays put.

The transfer-proof formula comes in three shades that adjust to work across all hair colors.

Price: $18
Stars: 4.3 / 5
Reviews: 16

Here is what one reviewer who tried KUSH Fiber Brow Gel had to say:

“I have never wanted to try a product like this… I have a brow pencil, but I get migraines and don’t want to rub my face at the end of the day to remove my makeup. I normally leave my brows in their natural state.

Anyway I am amused by the KUSH product line and decided to try this brow gel. I am pleasantly surprised by how nice it looks! Not super crunchy on my face and washes off easily. It adds a little bit of fullness and makes my brows look less crazy even when I have been lazy to give them the proper maintenance. The KUSH mascara is superb btw!” – laplacian

At Milk Makeup, they believe it’s not just about how you create your look; it’s what you do in it that matters. Their unique multi-use products are designed for an on-the-go lifestyle, with high-tech ingredients-without all the bad stuff. Milk Makeup is inspired by its home, Milk Studios, a cultural hub of creators in NY and LA. At Milk Makeup, there are no rules. Live Your Look.

KUSH Fiber Brow Gel, $18
Buy It


Tinted Brow Gel by Anastasia Beverly Hills

Anastasia Beverly Hills Tinted Brow Gel

A tinted brow gel.

Tinted Brow Gel by Anastasia Beverly Hills costs $22 – with 2,272 reviews and 4.2 out of 5 stars rating makes it an excellent option. It also has 60K ‘loves’ on Sephora.

Price: $22
Stars: 4.2 / 5
Reviews: 2,272

You can buy Tinted Brow Gel here.

Here is what people are saying about Tinted Brow Gel:

“This is my 1st Anastasia Product Purchased. My brows are full but a few spots need to be filled in. This Gel does just that. It instantly fills in my brows and changes my entire look. I LOVE IT!! It lasts all day and the hairs stay in place. ITS BEAUTIFUL. Quick and easy to apply. Only CON is that it has a weird smell to it (maybe its me).” – kuuipo83

Another user said:

“Cannot leave home without it. Helps me match my brows to my hair.” – VampX13

Tinted Brow Gel, $22
Buy It


ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush by Benefit Cosmetics

Benefit Cosmetics ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush

A waterproof cream-gel brow color that easily builds natural-looking to dramatic brows.

ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush by Benefit Cosmetics is priced at $24. This product has 1,396 reviews and 4.3 out of 5 star rating – making it a great choice. You can buy it now at Sephora today.

ka-BROW! features an all in one cream-gel formula with a built-in brush that glides on smoothly to easily shape, fill, and define brows. The 24-hour smudge-proof, waterproof color builds beautifully to create brow looks ranging from soft and natural to bold and dramatic. Transform the cap into a full length brush for extra precision and control by pulling the brush out of the cap, flipping it around and snapping it back in. A little goes a long way, so don’t be shy about dabbing any excess product off the brush before applying to each brow.

Beauty tip:
To add extra dimension to ka-BROW!, allow the cream-gel dry completely, then layer 3D Browtones Subtle Brow-Enhancing Highlights (sold separately) on top.

Price: $24
Stars: 4.3 / 5
Reviews: 1,396

Here is what one reviewer said about ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush:

“This stuff is amazing. It’s my favorite brow product. It’s waxy so it’s able to build up so it looks really natural and gives your brows some substance to them, which is good because I barely have any eyebrows. I think it’s great that they are now selling a mini size, which is exactly half the oz, and half the price, which makes it more affordable for many customers, and so it’s less likely to dry out before you finish it. FYI- I’ve seen multiple people commenting on how it dries out, true, but if you buy Ingolot Duraline from a major department store and put just a drop or two, stir, and your precious cream products will be back to normal. Another plus, you can turn any eyeshadow into eyeliner if you have the time to scrape the eyeshadow out and mix with the Ingolot Duraline, and apply! Don’t drip into your eyeshadow pan or you will ruin it!” – Desmakeupaddict

“Laughter is the best cosmetic, so grin & wear it!” – Jean & Jane Ford, co-founders. In 1976, former models Jean and Jane Ford opened a quirky boutique in San Francisco where they introduced the world’s first “Fake-Its”…instant beauty solutions with laugh-out-loud names and creative packaging. Benefit quickly became one of the world’s most beloved makeup brands and garnered a cult following among models, makeup artists, and celebrities. Now carried in over 35 countries, goodtime gals “fake it ‘til they make it” with iconic bestsellers like Benetint, the POREfessional, and They’re Real! mascara.

ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush, $24
Buy It


Arch Brow Volumizing Fiber Gel by Hourglass

Arch Brow Volumizing Fiber Gel

A buildable, tinted gel formula infused with micro fibers to provide color, volume, and definition for bold, fuller-looking brows.

This soft-hold, flexible formula is infused with micro fibers to create fuller-looking brows. The dual-sided brush features short and long bristles to apply the formula in varying intensities, making it easy to achieve either perfectly sculpted or natural looking, untamed brows. The brush is also designed to provide an even application of color every time, and the formula gives you long-lasting, comfortable wear without smudging or flaking.

Price: $28
Stars: 4.5 / 5
Reviews: 649

Here is what one of the users said about Arch Brow Volumizing Fiber Gel:

“I received this product for free from influenster to try, and honestly – I love it! I chose a lighter color since I normally do not wear a full face everyday. It looks so natural (I have VERY light and VERY sparse eyebrow hair) and its very easy to use.” – Deanababy27

Another reviewer said:

“This product did all that I hoped it would (really create volume in my brows and tint them with a natural color)… I literally have almost no brows and this product made my hair look more full and thick.. formula was comfortable and looked very natural and nice! Gel wasn’t crunchy at all and I really love how my brows turned out. I do wish the applicator was a little smaller (for my ‘tail’ hair on my brow), but overall amazing product! Really happy to have received this product for free to test from Influenster!” – alanachiles

Arch Brow Volumizing Fiber Gel, $28
Buy It


ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush Mini by Benefit Cosmetics

ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush Mini Benefit Cosmetics

A waterproof cream-gel brow color that easily builds natural-looking to dramatic brows.

ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush Mini is a great product, with 19 reviews, it is rated 4.2 out of 5 stars. ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush Mini has 3,958 ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it today for $12.

Now available in a perfect “try-me” size mini, Benefit’s ka-BROW! features an all-in-one cream-gel formula that glides on smoothly to easily shape, fill, and define brows. The 24-hour, smudge-proof, waterproof color builds beautifully to create brow looks ranging from soft and natural to bold and dramatic. Magically transform the cap into a full-length brush for extra precision and control by pulling the brush out of the cap, flipping it around and snapping it back in. A little goes a long way, so don’t be shy about dabbing any excess product off the brush before applying to each brow.

Beauty Tip:
To add extra dimension to your brows, allow the cream-gel to dry completely, then layer 3D BROWtones Subtle Brow-Enhancing Highlights (sold separately) on top.

Price: $12
Stars: 4.2 / 5
Reviews: 19

You can buy ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush Mini at Sephora.

Here is what one user who tried ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush Mini said:

“Definitely does it’s job and I really love it just don’t like how it drys our really easy I’ve only used it a handful of times and I already have to put oil on it to refresh it” – roze1207

ka-BROW! Cream-Gel Eyebrow Color with Brush Mini, $12
Buy It


Brow Tech To Go by Smashbox

Brow Tech To Go Smashbox

A double-ended applicator that has an angled long-wearing waterproof eyebrow pencil on one side and a soft-hold gel with a brow brush applicator on the other.

Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars, Brow Tech To Go by Smashbox is another great alternative. It currently has 735 reviews with 10K ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it for $28.

Create a soft, groomed look with this dual-ended stick. With an angled-tip pencil that precisely fills on one side and a soft-hold gel and brow brush on the other, setting brows perfectly into place has never been easier. The waterproof formula lasts for up to 16 hours and resists sweat and humidity.

Price: $28
Stars: 4.3 / 5
Reviews: 735

Here is what one user said about Brow Tech To Go:

“Bought this for my 15 year old daugher, she LOVED it until it broke approximately 2 weeks after purchase. The twist function stopped working, she couldn’t dial up the pencil. Very disappointing for the price.” – dkryan

Another reviewer said:

“I’ve transitioned from a benefit brow junkie to a Smashbox brow junkie. This product makes your brows look full and beautiful and I recommend it for everyone.” – EllaNikol

Brow Tech To Go, $28
Buy It


24-HR Brow Setter Shaping & Setting Gel by Benefit Cosmetics

Benefit Cosmetics 24-HR Brow Setter Shaping & Setting Gel

An invisible brow gel that shapes, sets, and locks in brow color for 24 hours.

Benefit Cosmetics’s 24-HR Brow Setter Shaping & Setting Gel is rated 4.2 out of 5 stars. This product has 247 reviews with 10K ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it for $24.

Hold eyebrows in place and keep them perfectly polished all day with this clear setting gel. The custom brush features long bristles that evenly coat brow hairs from root to tip and short bristles to sculpt and shape hairs into place. The flexible, flake-free and quick to dry formula applies easily to brows and locks on makeup for 24 hours.

Price: $24
Stars: 4.2 / 5
Reviews: 247

Here is what one reviewer who tried 24-HR Brow Setter Shaping & Setting Gel had to say:

“I love that this sets my brows and doesn’t add extra color. I walk to work in Georgia, so needless to say, I sweat. When I get home in the afternoon, my brows are mostly still there and that makes this girl happy.” – MissAshtastic

24-HR Brow Setter Shaping & Setting Gel, $24
Buy It


BROWVO! Conditioning Primer Nutrient Rich Eyebrow Primer by Benefit Cosmetics

Benefit Cosmetics BROWVO! Conditioning Primer Nutrient Rich Eyebrow Primer

A clear, nutrient-rich formula that primes and conditions for fuller, healthier-looking brows.

BROWVO! Conditioning Primer Nutrient Rich Eyebrow Primer by Benefit Cosmetics costs $28 – with 225 reviews and 4.1 out of 5 stars rating makes it a superb option. It also has 10K ‘loves’ on Sephora.

Take your eyebrows from sparse to seriously fuller-looking with BROWVO! Conditioning Primer. This nutrient-rich, conditioning primer is formulated with keratin and soy proteins-known to help brows look thicker, healthier, and fuller. The double-duty formula can be used as a primer to extend and enhance other brow products or worn alone to condition and smooth brows. The custom-designed soft-touch applicator coats brows from root to tip.

Price: $28
Stars: 4.1 / 5
Reviews: 225

You can buy BROWVO! Conditioning Primer Nutrient Rich Eyebrow Primer here.

Here is what people are saying about BROWVO! Conditioning Primer Nutrient Rich Eyebrow Primer:

“This product actually works, I was a little wary at first but in the matter of 2 weeks my brow hair doubled in growth and new hairs started growing in” – KailaMac

Another user said:

“This product does exactly what it claims to! It primed so my brow product goes on smoother and nicer, and it also conditions and has encouraged growth! My brows are much fuller now and people have told me I have brow goals, when a year ago girls used to make fun of my brows and say I had thing macaroni brows. This product is extremely helpful to me since I naturally have almost clearing orange brows (I’m ginger) and they are very thin… not anymore! So full!” – Keelynnkeen

BROWVO! Conditioning Primer Nutrient Rich Eyebrow Primer, $28
Buy It