Are you looking for the best Highlighters to buy? You’ve come to the right place! We’ve looked over hundreds of Makeup products to come up with this comprehensive list of the best Highlighters you can buy right now. Many of these are best-selling and top rated products at popular cosmetic stores such as Sephora, Bergdorf Goodman, Nordstrom, C.O. Bigelow and Lush. In this post, we’re going to take a look at products from Benefit Cosmetics, Yves Saint Laurent, BURBERRY, Wander Beauty, and others. In this list we include Secret Weapon Multitasking Pencil by Wander Beauty, Skin Glossing Pencil by NUDESTIX, and Eye Colour Contour Smoke & Sculpt Pen by BURBERRY.

There are many things to consider before choosing makeup – quality, durability, skin tone and skin type. Understand your skin, face type, and complexion. It’s difficult to know exactly what you are looking for, but we try our best to make our list as precise as possible.

With the wide range of items to choose from in the cosmetic shops, it becomes quite a task to choose something that can suit your requirements and leave you looking gorgeous. Most people buy makeup on impulse and thus do not have the time to go through the merits of getting a particular product. The sellers understand this behavior and capitalize on it to increase their sales by offering good marketing promises.

So which is the best Highlighters for you? Discover below.

Quick Look: 5 Best Highlighters

  • City Lights, Party Nights Set by Benefit Cosmetics
  • Eye Colour Contour Smoke & Sculpt Pen by BURBERRY
  • TOUCHE ECLAT – Strobing Light Highlighter by Yves Saint Laurent
  • Secret Weapon Multitasking Pencil by Wander Beauty
  • Skin Glossing Pencil by NUDESTIX
Below you will find product details, along with the most useful reviews and buy links for each Makeup product. This list will be updated with new products as they are released. So check back often.

City Lights, Party Nights Set by Benefit Cosmetics

City Lights, Party Nights Set Benefit Cosmetics

City Lights, Party Nights Set is one of the best-selling products right now, with 27 reviews, it is rated 4.4 out of 5 stars. City Lights, Party Nights Set has 9,155 ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it today for $32 ($65 value).

A limited-edition set of bestselling products for brows, cheeks, lips, and eyes.

The hottest holiday makeup look is in the bag. This limited-edition set of benefit favorites contains everything you need to get precisely defined brows, long lashes, full-looking lips, and a soft glow. Plus, this collection comes in a custom-designed bag that fits into most purses, just in case you need a touch up post-mistletoe.

Price: $32 ($65 value)
Stars: 4.4 / 5
Reviews: 27

You can buy City Lights, Party Nights Set at Sephora.

A reviewer who tried City Lights, Party Nights Set said:

“This is a great set, you get a bag plus three mini size products and a full size product. LOOOOVVVEEE!! Can create a whole look with this!” – Essssss

“Laughter is the best cosmetic, so grin & wear it!” – Jean & Jane Ford, co-founders. In 1976, former models Jean and Jane Ford opened a quirky boutique in San Francisco where they introduced the world’s first “Fake-Its”…instant beauty solutions with laugh-out-loud names and creative packaging. Benefit quickly became one of the world’s most beloved makeup brands and garnered a cult following among models, makeup artists, and celebrities. Now carried in over 35 countries, goodtime gals “fake it ‘til they make it” with iconic bestsellers like Benetint, the POREfessional, and They’re Real! mascara.

City Lights, Party Nights Set, $32 ($65 value)
Buy It

Eye Colour Contour Smoke & Sculpt Pen by BURBERRY

Eye Colour Contour Smoke & Sculpt Pen BURBERRY

A mistake-proof stick designed to sculpt and smoke eyes with precision, delivering an all-day flawless finish.

Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars, Eye Colour Contour Smoke & Sculpt Pen by BURBERRY is another fantastic option. It currently has 38 reviews with 9,155 ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it for around $29.5.

Burberry Eye Colour Contour Smoke & Sculpt Pen creates effortless smoky or sculpted eye looks. Designed with a precision dome tip, the pen fits naturally into the curve of the eye for quick and easy application. The blendable, creamy formula delivers crease-free and waterproof eye color with no powder residue fall-out for an all-day flawless finish. Available in a range of modern-neutral shades, it can be worn alone or layered for multiple eye looks. Crease-free and waterproof for an all-day flawless finish, create multiple eye looks using lighter shades to illuminate and widen eyes before adding depth and vibrancy with more intense colors.

Price: $29.5
Stars: 4.2 / 5
Reviews: 38

Eye Colour Contour Smoke & Sculpt Pen is available at Sephora.

Here is what one user said about Eye Colour Contour Smoke & Sculpt Pen:

“I was looking for a cream shadow in a stick for travel, and this one is gorgeous! It’s sleek and it goes on so creamy and smooth, and it lasts all day. The only problem is that the colour I ordered doesn’t look good on me. I bought Pale Copper and it looks really orange on my fair skin. I wish I could order samples of things not available in the store. So many times I am returning things because the colour doesn’t look good on me. Oh well, I will try again!” – cheribomb

Another reviewer said:

“These pens are worth every penny – they are easy to use, save so much time, and won’t budge from your lids.

I fell in love with the NARS Velvet Shadow Stick but was disappointed in the range of colors, so I started exploring other similar products. I was looking for something in a smoky purple and a grey, and lo and behold discovered this product in Dusky Mauve and Stone Grey.

I have oily lids and always have problems with shadows staying put, regardless of the primer I use. But these have incredible staying power yet are easy to blend and remove at the end of the day.

The Dusky Mauve wears a little more gray than I expected but it’s beautiful. It says it’s a matte finish but I do find it to have some shimmer to it – the perfect amount. The Stone Grey is very matte – too much so for me. So really, the fact that the Dusky Mauve turned out to be more grey than expected worked out perfectly.” – tm82

Eye Colour Contour Smoke & Sculpt Pen, $29.5
Buy It

TOUCHE ECLAT – Strobing Light Highlighter by Yves Saint Laurent

Yves Saint Laurent TOUCHE ECLAT - Strobing Light Highlighter

A liquid-shimmer gold highlighter to create a radiant and glittering, incandescent glow.

Yves Saint Laurent’s TOUCHE ECLAT – Strobing Light Highlighter is rated 3.4 out of 5 stars. This product has 62 reviews with 3,210 ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it for $38.

Add just the right amount of micro-gold shimmer to anywhere the light would naturally hit your face. The ultra-lightweight, iconic Touche Éclat now features a strobing formula that spotlights your cheekbones, browbones, down the bridge of the nose, and above the cupid’s bow, for a gorgeous, subtle glow.

Beauty tip:
Lightly tap the product with a foundation brush onto skin. To enhance the shimmery finish, add a drop of Touche Éclat Blur Primer to the skin before applying the Strobing Light. The buildable formula allows you to customize your glow.

Price: $38
Stars: 3.4 / 5
Reviews: 62

Here is what one reviewer who tried TOUCHE ECLAT – Strobing Light Highlighter had to say:

“Awful! When I put it on I thought maybe I had some sort of other product on my brush and that is why there was so much glitter. It is gold glitter all over the place. I put a little on my forehead and it looked ridiculous. A highlighter is supposed to brighten. even a more dramatic one will just have a bright sheen. This is all gold glitter. Thanks god I just got a sample and didn’t waste my money” – NV0514

Yves Saint Laurent reigns as one of the most influential and inspired designers in the world. From his early days in the studio of Christian Dior to his acclaimed haute couture collections of today, YSL’s touch remains unmistakable. The YSL style is reflected in the realm of fashion, including accessories, jewelry, ready-to-wear, fragrance, and cosmetics.

TOUCHE ECLAT – Strobing Light Highlighter, $38
Buy It

Secret Weapon Multitasking Pencil by Wander Beauty

Wander Beauty Secret Weapon Multitasking Pencil

A multitasking, hydrating, precision pencil that instantly brightens eyes, highlights brows, and defines lips.

Secret Weapon Multitasking Pencil by Wander Beauty costs $23 – with 6 reviews and 4.5 out of 5 stars rating makes it an excellent option. It also has 1,250 ‘loves’ on Sephora.

The luxuriously long-wearing Secret Weapon Multitasking Pencil offers three-in-one, waterproof benefits for the eyes, lips, and brows. The blendable formula is enriched with a skin-conditioning complex of moisturizing olive fruit oil from Spain, jojoba oil from Uruguay, and vitamin E from Germany to lock in moisture and create a matte, velvety finish that lasts. The applicator tip conveniently twists up with a built-in sharpener for intense precision on the go. Just glide this creamy liner along the lower, inner rim and the inner corner of eyes for a wide-awake look. It can also be used to contour and accentuate the lip line, prevent lipstick from bleeding or smudging, or to give brows added shape and definition in a single stroke.

Price: $23
Stars: 4.5 / 5
Reviews: 6

You can buy Secret Weapon Multitasking Pencil here.

Here is what people are saying about Secret Weapon Multitasking Pencil:

“It is a good color for me on inner rim of eyelid. Makes me appear younger, fresher. I really like the look. Especially a plus in allergy season.

However, like other reviewers, I have also found that it doesn’t last very long. I’m not sure it’s even lasting until I get out of the house. I don’t reapply throughout the day, so this really limits its usefulness for me.

The real reason I purchased was the idea of “multitasking.” That really appealed. But I tried the suggested uses in corner of eyes, underlining brows, outlining lips. I could have totally misunderstood how this thing is to be used in those places, but I couldn’t get anything useful anywhere but the eyelid.

Otherwise: doesn’t cause eye watering for me even though many other products do; soft & easy to apply, but clumps in eyelashes if I’m not careful.

Overall, because it wears off so fast, not a big hit for me. 5 stars for the look, 2 stars for the abysmally short wear. (Ignoring the nonexistent “multitasking”) Bottom of the bag; use once in awhile; won’t repurchase.” – Helphathope

Another user said:

“I love this eye pencil for the inner corners! I love how it is an off white, so it blends and looks more natural. It’s definitely long lasting so great along the water line as well. Be careful not to put too much pressure, since it is so fine it breaks easily. Totally recommend!” – Erinrichelle

Secret Weapon Multitasking Pencil, $23
Buy It

Skin Glossing Pencil by NUDESTIX

NUDESTIX Skin Glossing Pencil

A multitasking, sheer, skin glossing stick that provides a fresh glow to the complexion, lips, and cheeks.

Skin Glossing Pencil by NUDESTIX is priced at $24. This product has 18 reviews and 3.6 out of 5 star rating – making it a great choice. You can buy it now at Sephora today.

This innovative nude highlighter provides translucent shine and natural glow without adding color to the face. It’s formulated with 30 percent super-hydrating lip-protecting plant oils derived from rapeseed, sunflower, cottonseed, and soybean. Lightweight and translucent, it leaves lips with a cushiony feel.

Achieve a wearable runway-to-hallway glossy look by applying to the high points of the face, Cupid’s bow and eyelids. Skin Glossing Pencil glides on to add dimension and a natural glow. Gel polymers provide a fresh, wet gloss that is never sticky.

Price: $24
Stars: 3.6 / 5
Reviews: 18

Here is what one reviewer said about Skin Glossing Pencil:

“Got this and it basically just smeared my makeup. Was not overly impressed so I just returned it.” – kortenie

Makeup crayons for all faces, in all places. Created and modeled by sisters Ally and Taylor Frankel.

Skin Glossing Pencil, $24
Buy It