Are you looking for the best Eyebrow Pencils to buy? You’ve come to the right place! We’ve looked over hundreds of Makeup products to come up with this comprehensive list of the best Eyebrow Pencils you can buy right now. Many of these are best-selling and top rated products at popular cosmetic stores such as Sephora, Bergdorf Goodman, Nordstrom, C.O. Bigelow and Lush. In this post, we’re going to take a look at products from Anastasia Beverly Hills, Dior, Kat Von D, Benefit Cosmetics, and others. In this list we include Brow Zings Tame & Shape Kit by Benefit Cosmetics, Eyebrow Editor Complete Brow Kit by SEPHORA COLLECTION, and Brow Struck Dimension Powder by Kat Von D.
There are many things to consider before choosing makeup – quality, durability, skin tone and skin type. Understand your skin, face type, and complexion. It’s difficult to know exactly what you are looking for, but we try our best to make our list as precise as possible.
With the wide range of items to choose from in the cosmetic shops, it becomes quite a task to choose something that can suit your requirements and leave you looking gorgeous. Most people buy makeup on impulse and thus do not have the time to go through the merits of getting a particular product. The sellers understand this behavior and capitalize on it to increase their sales by offering good marketing promises.
So which is the best Eyebrow Pencils for you? Discover below.
Quick Look: 10 Best Eyebrow Pencils
- Brow Powder Duo by Anastasia Beverly Hills
- Brow Struck Dimension Powder by Kat Von D
- BACKSTAGE Brow Palette by Dior
- Brow Zings Tame & Shape Kit by Benefit Cosmetics
- Eyebrow Editor Complete Brow Kit by SEPHORA COLLECTION
- Foolproof Brow Powder by Benefit Cosmetics
- #SHAPEMATTERS PALETTE by Smashbox
- Classic Double Ended – Filler & Spoolie #208 by SEPHORA COLLECTION
- City Lights, Party Nights Set by Benefit Cosmetics
- Brow Box by Urban Decay
Brow Powder Duo by Anastasia Beverly Hills
Brow Powder Duo is one of the best-selling products right now, with 4,060 reviews, it is rated 4.7 out of 5 stars. Brow Powder Duo has 110K ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it today for $23.
A two-shade brow powder compact that creates a natural brow.
Create beautiful and natural brow effects with Anastasia’s bestselling Brow Powder Duo. This lightweight, sheer to medium coverage formula was designed to be smudge-proof and comes with two shades per compact to ensure the perfect brow color.
The Medium Brown shade is an Allure Best of Beauty award winner.
Stars: 4.7 / 5
You can buy Brow Powder Duo at Sephora.
A reviewer who tried Brow Powder Duo said:
“Got this today. I love it. It really looks natural to fill in those sparse areas in brows.
I have always had thick brows so had never needed any kind of product to fill them in.
As I have been getting older my brows have been getting thinner and I needed something that looked natural to fill those spaces. This product is perfect for that. Amazing!” – balilo
Anastasia Soare is widely referred to as a beauty innovator, and for good reason. Long before professional eyebrow shaping became an essential beauty ritual, she was the go-to beauty specialist for top celebrities, and has singlehandedly turned perfect brows and youthful eyes into essential accessories. Anastasia’s comprehensive approach to beauty has led to the development of her unique Youthful Synergy products, which lift and firm the appearance of skin using innovative ingredients. Discover the beauty of Anastasia combined with the science of skincare.
Brow Powder Duo, $23
Brow Struck Dimension Powder by Kat Von D
A long-wear, waterproof brow powder infused with light-catching 3D pigments for realistic dimension and volume.
Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars, Brow Struck Dimension Powder by Kat Von D is another fantastic option. It currently has 88 reviews with 110K ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it for around $20.
For perfectly full- and balanced-looking brows, Brow Struck Dimension Powder fills in and evens out your shape with a realistic, hair-like finish. Featuring a hybrid two-in-one primer and powder formula to enhance grip and wear time, Brow Struck Dimension Powder is Kat’s first powder to deliver waterproof, smudge-resistant brows for up to 12 hours.
Brow Struck Dimension Powder makes it easier than ever to create a natural-looking brow-use the #75 Powder Brow Brush (sold separately) to fill in any sparse spots to rock soft, natural, and insanely believable brows. Innovative 3D reflective pigments amplify depth and dimension in medium to full brows, while the semi-metallic finish mimics the sheen of real hair.
Choose from seven natural shades, hand-picked for every brow tone. Kat Von D’s Brow Collection features the same shade in every format, so you can mix and match your favorite products to create your custom brow look.
Kat Von D’s Brow Collection empowers you to own whatever brow look you want with confidence-whether they’re soft and natural, crisp and defined, or a rainbow-bright work of art. There are no rules in makeup, especially when it comes to your brows, so feel free to craft and color with complete creative freedom.
Stars: 4.4 / 5
Brow Struck Dimension Powder is available at Sephora.
Here is what one user said about Brow Struck Dimension Powder:
“I love this brow powder! I have decently full brows and this gives me a precise yet still natural look when applied. It creates much more of an impact than other brow products I’ve used. After using it for over a week I don’t notice the micro glitter, but I also use a spoolie on my brows after I apply the product. Only giving it four stars as it doesn’t live up to the waterproof claim.” – cose
Another reviewer said:
“I just got through reading several of the 1-2 star reviews and was a bit surprised. I feel that the product description accurately describes the glitter/shimmer that most of the negative reviews mention as the reason for giving a low score. This is the best brow powder I have ever owned and the staying bower is amazing!!!! 6 out of 5 stars for me!” – GormaniaVT
Brow Struck Dimension Powder, $20
BACKSTAGE Brow Palette by Dior
A long-wearing and blendable eyebrow palette to fill, set, and shape the brows.
Dior’s BACKSTAGE Brow Palette is rated 5 out of 5 stars. This product has 8 reviews with 957 ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it for $35.
The Backstage Brow Palette is the Dior makeup artist’s secret weapon to create a perfectly-groomed brow look-whether natural or more defined. It offers blendable powders to customize your shade and make it yours.
This all-in-one brow palette has everything you need to expertly fill, shape, and define your brows. It includes a setting wax that sets brow hairs and holds its shape throughout the day, as well as two ultra-fine shades of powder with buildable coverage that naturally redefine the brows.
The Dior Backstage Brow palette is available in two harmonies. Light includes cappuccino shades to structure naturally light eyebrows. Dark includes warm shades for naturally dark eyebrows.
Stars: 5 / 5
Here is what one reviewer who tried BACKSTAGE Brow Palette had to say:
“Go to brow palette! So pigmented and easy to use, I prefer this over my Anastasia brow powder! New favorite!” – re1axed
From catwalk-inspired cosmetics to cutting-edge skin care and timeless fragrances, Christian Dior has brought us some of the most luxurious, trendsetting, and fashionable beauty products around. It’s this magical mix of couture-meets-cosmetics that not only attracts celebrities, supermodels, and the society set, but also has solidified Dior’s reputation as one of the most unabashedly stylish beauty brands in the world.
BACKSTAGE Brow Palette, $35
Brow Zings Tame & Shape Kit by Benefit Cosmetics
An all-in-one eyebrow kit that includes everything you need to tame, shape, and fill brows.
Brow Zings Tame & Shape Kit by Benefit Cosmetics costs $32 – with 1,635 reviews and 4.4 out of 5 stars rating makes it an excellent option. It also has 10K ‘loves’ on Sephora.
This all-in-one kit for eyebrows features a soft, pigmented wax to create shape and definition and a setting powder to give brows 12-hour wear. Brow Zings is perfectly purse sized and includes a double-ended brush and mini slant tweezers so you can tweeze, shape, fill, and set brows anywhere you go. Available in an array of shades, it’s perfect for pulling off gorgeous brows.
Stars: 4.4 / 5
You can buy Brow Zings Tame & Shape Kit here.
Here is what people are saying about Brow Zings Tame & Shape Kit:
“I really don’t know how I ever got along without this product and I’ll never go back to pencils again. Your brows don’t have that ‘drawn on’ look – very natural.” – MiaMc
Another user said:
“The best brow product ever. Hands down. Lasts all day and looks great.” – sugarhousebabe
Brow Zings Tame & Shape Kit, $32
Eyebrow Editor Complete Brow Kit by SEPHORA COLLECTION
A complete kit for expertly shaping, grooming, and defining your brows.
Eyebrow Editor Complete Brow Kit by SEPHORA COLLECTION is priced at $9 ($19 value). This product has 346 reviews and 4.2 out of 5 star rating – making it a great choice. You can buy it now at Sephora today.
Get the arch you’ve always wanted with this collection of brow essentials. This compact kit includes everything you need for customizing your look, including two brow powders that can be combined to create your perfect filler shade. Apply these defining powders with the included angle brush and then follow up with the spoolie brush for specialized shaping. The kit also includes a tweezer for shaping and a setting wax to keep unruly brows in line.
Price: $9 ($19 value)
Stars: 4.2 / 5
Here is what one reviewer said about Eyebrow Editor Complete Brow Kit:
“I’m asian with brown-black hair and the #2 Nutmeg works perfect for my brows. You can make your brows look super natural or more defined depending on how much shadow you use. The brushes included work great and I was surprised by how well the tweezers work too. Perfect for travel.” – candiceheejin
Beauty Uncomplicated | What good are tons of options if you can’t figure out how to choose between them? SEPHORA COLLECTION is about formulas that really deliver, paired with bite-sized bits of Sephora expertise that make all those options less overwhelming. Whether you’re looking for a new color, a new formula, or even a whole new look, with SEPHORA COLLECTION it’s easy to get exactly what you want.
Eyebrow Editor Complete Brow Kit, $9 ($19 value)
Foolproof Brow Powder by Benefit Cosmetics
An eyebrow powder for natural-looking fullness.
Transform sparse brows into full-looking brows. This powder instantly fills your brows to create a soft, natural brow look with its velvety smooth, 12-hour formula that adheres to hair and skin. The lighter-to-darker shade duos mimic the gradual ombré of natural brows, and the eyebrow-shaped pan makes for an easy, guided application with no hard lines or mistakes.
Stars: 4.3 / 5
Here is what one of the users said about Foolproof Brow Powder:
“Best brow powder!! Only one I use. Give the best defined brow!” – janiquevan
Another reviewer said:
“I wear very basic makeup and this product looks natural and is easy to use. I just need to fill in some holes in my brows and this is perfect. I do, however, use a small angled brush instead of the sponge applicator because I felt like the sponge wasn’t getting the powder behind the existing hairs. I use the brush inside the applicator though and love that.” – Cind44
Foolproof Brow Powder, $24
#SHAPEMATTERS PALETTE by Smashbox
A one-kit-wonder with a mix of 16 eyeshadows, eyebrow powders and wax, and face essentials to contour, highlight and enhance your unique features.
#SHAPEMATTERS PALETTE is a great product, with 519 reviews, it is rated 4.3 out of 5 stars. #SHAPEMATTERS PALETTE has 70K ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it today for $55 ($276 value).
Define your eyes with nine richly-pigmented eyeshadows ranging from smoky mattes to warm shimmers. Easily sculpt cheekbones with one bronzer, one contour shade, and two highlighters. Create perfectly-arched eyebrows with two brow powders and a brow wax. The kit even comes with a lookbook so you can learn tips and techniques to accentuate your favorite features.
Price: $55 ($276 value)
Stars: 4.3 / 5
You can buy #SHAPEMATTERS PALETTE at Sephora.
Here is what one user who tried #SHAPEMATTERS PALETTE said:
“When I saw this palette I knew that I had to get it. The colors are absolutely gorgeous. The eyeshadow is very opaque and depending on what look you’re going for can be used sparingly or layered for a deeper color. My issue is that the contour and the shadows have a lot of fallout. My case is constantly being wiped down because theres fallout all over the place. While it goes on smoothly, the fallout is a bit of a concern. Also, I wish that the brow color was lighter. I have white blonde hair and when I use this brow filler it makes my brows look dark and not at all natural. The contour is amazing, I love having everything in once place. What would make this palette better is if it included a blush. Another thing I enjoyed was the how-to videos for this palettte. I consider myself to be good with makeup for the most part but I am always eager to try new things and new techniques. I think that this palette is well worth the money because you are getting so much product.” – Ariel90
#SHAPEMATTERS PALETTE, $55 ($276 value)
Classic Double Ended – Filler & Spoolie #208 by SEPHORA COLLECTION
A double-ended eyebrow tool that features an angled brush and comb in one.
Rated 3.6 out of 5 stars, Classic Double Ended – Filler & Spoolie #208 by SEPHORA COLLECTION is another great alternative. It currently has 46 reviews with 5,474 ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it for $12.
This classic makeup essential flawlessly applies brow pigments, shapes, and combs out fine eyebrow hairs for sleek, natural, and bold looks. Designed for user-friendly and on-the-go application, both straightforward ends are made of high-quality materials for a flawless finish.
Stars: 3.6 / 5
Here is what one user said about Classic Double Ended – Filler & Spoolie #208:
“This brush is easy to use and gets the job done. I do wish that the filler end was a bit thinner for more precise lines and the spoolie was slightly smaller for better control, but overall, it’s a handy tool that works well, also great for travel and on-the-go!” – KateMay87
Another reviewer said:
“My eyebrow game changed forever! I use this brush along with Anastasia’s dip brow and I always get complimented on my brows, even from men lol. I haven’t used it for anything else but definitely my official brow brush.” – bellamassarotti
Classic Double Ended – Filler & Spoolie #208, $12
City Lights, Party Nights Set by Benefit Cosmetics
A limited-edition set of bestselling products for brows, cheeks, lips, and eyes.
Benefit Cosmetics’s City Lights, Party Nights Set is rated 4.4 out of 5 stars. This product has 27 reviews with 9,155 ‘loves’ on Sephora. You can buy it for $32 ($65 value).
The hottest holiday makeup look is in the bag. This limited-edition set of benefit favorites contains everything you need to get precisely defined brows, long lashes, full-looking lips, and a soft glow. Plus, this collection comes in a custom-designed bag that fits into most purses, just in case you need a touch up post-mistletoe.
Price: $32 ($65 value)
Stars: 4.4 / 5
Here is what one reviewer who tried City Lights, Party Nights Set had to say:
“This is a great set, you get a bag plus three mini size products and a full size product. LOOOOVVVEEE!! Can create a whole look with this!” – Essssss
City Lights, Party Nights Set, $32 ($65 value)
Brow Box by Urban Decay
Everything you need for amazing brows packed into a convenient, palm-size kit.
Brow Box by Urban Decay costs $30 – with 720 reviews and 4.4 out of 5 stars rating makes it a superb option. It also has 10K ‘loves’ on Sephora.
This convenient brow tool kit containstwo shades of brow color, perfecting/setting wax, high-quality metal mini tweezers that really work, two mini angled brushes, and two mirrors (one of them magnifies so you won’t miss a single stray). The double-layer mini compact features a top tier that holds the powders and wax and a bottom tier that holds all the tools.
Stars: 4.4 / 5
You can buy Brow Box here.
Here is what people are saying about Brow Box:
“A little goes a long way for the powder. The wax was very good but throughout the day I noticed that it didn’t hold my brows in place. It’s very travel friendly and I love how it comes with 2 brushes! Only downside is that there should be a spooly brush included.” – PrincessAnnika
Another user said:
“My last brow box lasted an entire year! I love the way it looks so natural, and how you can change from daytime to more dramatic evening.” – kelllyo
Brow Box, $30